Off-Market Real Estate Opportunities in Miami’s Private Islands

When it comes to luxury real estate, Miami is synonymous with high-end living, breathtaking views, and unparalleled exclusivity. But for the ultra-elite, the most coveted properties aren’t just in the towering skyscrapers or beachfront mansions—they’re on Miami’s private islands. With names like Fisher Island, Star Island, and Indian Creek, these islands are home to some of the most luxurious and private real estate in the world. For buyers seeking ultimate privacy, discretion, and exclusivity, off-market real estate opportunities on these islands offer the pinnacle of luxury living.

This guide will walk you through the allure of Miami’s private islands and how you can discover hidden, off-market gems that rarely, if ever, hit the public market.

Why Choose Off-Market Properties?
Off-market properties, also known as “pocket listings,” are real estate opportunities that are not publicly listed on the MLS (Multiple Listing Service). Sellers of these properties often choose to keep the sale discreet, only offering them to a select group of high-net-worth individuals through private networks.

In the case of Miami’s private islands, off-market listings are highly coveted for several reasons:

Discretion: Buyers and sellers of ultra-luxury properties often prioritize privacy. Off-market sales help avoid public attention and media scrutiny, keeping transactions out of the spotlight.
Exclusive Access: With off-market properties, you’re not competing with the general public. This exclusivity gives you a competitive edge in securing a property that might not even be known to other potential buyers.
Unique and Rare Listings: Some of Miami’s most sought-after homes, especially on private islands, rarely enter the public market. Off-market sales are often the only way to access these one-of-a-kind properties.
Fisher Island: The Ultimate in Exclusivity
Fisher Island is the epitome of privacy and luxury. Accessible only by ferry or private yacht, this ultra-exclusive island is home to some of the wealthiest individuals in the world. With a limited number of residences, the real estate here is as scarce as it is luxurious.

Off-Market Opportunities on Fisher Island:
Off-market properties on Fisher Island are especially desirable due to the island’s tight-knit, private community. These homes often boast sprawling waterfront views, private beaches, and world-class amenities. From palatial condos to expansive penthouses, off-market listings on Fisher Island represent some of Miami’s most discreet and exclusive real estate opportunities.

For buyers seeking off-market homes on Fisher Island, working with top-tier real estate brokers who specialize in luxury pocket listings is key. Fisher Island’s residents value privacy above all, and only select brokers have access to these elite listings.

Star Island: A Celebrity Favorite
Star Island is perhaps Miami’s most iconic private island, known for its grand estates and celebrity residents. Located just off the coast of South Beach, Star Island is a man-made paradise with an ultra-exclusive community of only 30 homes.

Off-Market Opportunities on Star Island:
Homes on Star Island offer expansive waterfront lots, private docks, and unobstructed views of Biscayne Bay and the Miami skyline. Off-market properties here often feature custom-built mansions designed for the ultimate in luxury living. From sprawling estates with private tennis courts and swimming pools to exclusive yacht access, Star Island is home to some of Miami’s most opulent properties.

Given the high-profile nature of many Star Island residents, off-market listings are common, as sellers prefer to keep transactions private. For buyers seeking a discreet purchase on Star Island, working through private networks or luxury real estate agencies with established relationships is the best way to uncover these hidden gems.

Indian Creek: The Billionaire Bunker
Often referred to as “Billionaire Bunker,” Indian Creek is one of the most exclusive private islands in the world. Located on a small barrier island, Indian Creek is home to only 40 residents, many of whom are among the wealthiest individuals in the world. The island boasts its own private police force and country club, ensuring the highest level of security and privacy.

Off-Market Opportunities on Indian Creek:
The island’s sprawling estates are tucked away behind towering gates and lush landscaping, offering some of the most private living spaces in Miami. Off-market properties on Indian Creek are rare, and when they do become available, they are only accessible to a select group of buyers through private channels. These properties often feature enormous lots with private golf course access, custom-built mansions, and waterfront views with yacht docks.

For those looking to purchase on Indian Creek, the key to finding off-market opportunities lies in working with real estate agents who have deep ties to the ultra-wealthy community on the island. It’s a small and highly exclusive world, and only a handful of brokers are trusted with access to these listings.

How to Find Off-Market Listings in Miami’s Private Islands
Accessing off-market properties on Miami’s private islands requires connections, discretion, and working with the right professionals. Here are some tips for navigating the off-market real estate world:

Work with a Luxury Real Estate Specialist: Not all agents have access to off-market listings. It’s essential to work with a luxury real estate agent who specializes in high-end properties and has established relationships with other agents and property owners on Miami’s private islands.
Leverage Private Networks: Off-market properties are often shared through exclusive networks of high-net-worth individuals. Joining private real estate groups or working with an agent who has access to these networks can open doors to listings that aren’t available to the general public.
Maintain Discretion: Off-market sales are all about privacy, so it’s crucial to respect the seller’s need for discretion. Keep discussions about the property within a trusted circle and avoid sharing details publicly.
Be Prepared to Act Quickly: Off-market listings on Miami’s private islands can move quickly, given their exclusivity. If you’re serious about buying, be ready to act swiftly when a property becomes available.
Have Your Finances in Order: Given the high price point of homes on Miami’s private islands, it’s essential to have your finances ready. Sellers of off-market properties often prefer cash buyers or those who can move quickly through the purchase process.
Conclusion
Off-market real estate opportunities on Miami’s private islands, including Fisher Island, Star Island, and Indian Creek, represent the pinnacle of luxury and exclusivity. These hidden gems offer a unique chance to live among Miami’s elite, with privacy, discretion, and world-class amenities at your fingertips.

For buyers looking to secure a slice of paradise on one of these ultra-exclusive islands, working with a trusted luxury real estate broker and leveraging private networks are key. With the right connections, you can discover a world of off-market opportunities that offer the ultimate in luxury living, away from the public eye.

Tags: Real Estate, Miami Market, Private Islands


Back to Blog

Latest Posts

  • Florida Becomes The Most Valuable Housing Market In The U.S.

    Florida has ascended to the coveted second spot in the ranking of the most valuable housing markets in the United States. This news comes as no surprise to those who have been closely following the state’s real estate scene. Florida’s steady growth and undeniable allure have made it a top destination for homebuyers, investors, and […]

    Read more
  • Celebrity Real Estate Trends: How High-Profile Sales Shape Miami’s Ultra-Luxury Market

    Miami’s ultra-luxury market is buzzing as high-profile celebrities make it their home, spurring a ripple effect on property values, styles, and demand. Recent sales by stars like David Beckham, Pharrell Williams, and Shakira have done more than grab headlines; they’re influencing Miami’s real estate landscape in a big way. When celebrities purchase homes in areas […]

    Read more
  • The Rise of Green Roofs and Eco-Friendly Outdoor Spaces in Miami’s Luxury Condos

    In response to a growing demand for sustainable living, Miami’s luxury condos are increasingly embracing green roofs, rooftop gardens, and eco-friendly outdoor spaces. These features are redefining urban living, combining opulence with a commitment to the environment and appealing strongly to eco-conscious buyers. Green roofs are among the most popular additions in high-end Miami condos […]

    Read more
  • Art as an Investment: How Art Deco and Mid-Century Modern Homes in Miami Are Gaining Value

    Miami’s Art Deco and mid-century modern homes are more than just architectural gems; they’re becoming high-value investments for savvy buyers. Known for their iconic design elements—think pastel facades, geometric lines, and nautical motifs—these homes carry a rich history that has cemented their appeal for both locals and investors. The Art Deco style, with its roots […]

    Read more
  • Pet-Friendly Penthouse Living: Miami’s Most Luxurious High-Rises with Pet Amenities

    Miami’s luxury condo market isn’t just catering to human residents—it’s creating a paradise for pets, too. For those who want the best in high-rise living without leaving behind their furry friends’ needs, several high-end Miami condos now offer pet-friendly amenities that go above and beyond. At Paramount Miami Worldcenter, residents have access to a rooftop […]

    Read more

Subscribe To Receive Our Newsletter And Communication

Edit Search

  • Email Updates
  • Only Update me On
Close
Email Sent! Your email was sent successfully
Close
Register
  • Thank You For Registering

    Just a few more details so we can help you

    (All fields are required)

    When are you looking to purchase?
  • Thank You For Registering

    Just a few more details so we can help you

    (All fields are required)

    Need assistance with financing?
  • Thank You For Registering

    Just a few more details so we can help you

    (All fields are required)

    Need to also sell your property?